The Grass Isn’t Always Greener: Ontario’s Letters to Its Busiest Doctors

Read the article: CBC News: Ontario doctors seek apology over letters flagging high-volume billings

In late October, Ontario’s Ministry of Health sent letters to hundreds of physicians noting a “high number of days worked in a single year.” The letters came from the ministry’s Payment Accountability and Fraud Control Unit. They did not say how many days was too many, or what threshold had been crossed. The Ontario Medical Association says the letters punish doctors for doing more work, warned of a chilling effect on physicians willing to take on extra hours, and has asked the province for an apology and an explanation of how doctors were selected.

To be fair, the letters did not come out of nowhere. A December 2025 report from Ontario’s Auditor General found that the province’s oversight of physician billing was weak, including dozens of doctors each year billing for more than 24 hours of services in a single day. The ministry says the letters are meant to educate and do not assume anything inappropriate. There is a real problem here. But a letter from a fraud unit, sent to a family doctor who has been working hard to see more patients, is a blunt instrument.

Why this should feel familiar

Any American physician will recognize this. Our version comes from payers rather than a provincial ministry: prior authorizations, documentation audits, utilization reviews, and letters questioning our patterns of care. In the AMA’s most recent survey, physicians reported completing roughly 40 prior authorizations a week. Each piece of oversight can be defended on its own. Together, they pull time and attention away from the work we trained to do, and they send a message about trust that physicians hear loud and clear.

The grass isn’t always greener

In the United States we often hold up Canada’s health system as a North Star. There is a lot to learn from it. But a single payer does not eliminate administrative oversight; it changes who is doing the overseeing. Every system has to balance paying for care against guarding against waste and fraud, and every system gets that balance wrong sometimes. The lesson isn’t that one model is good and another is bad. It’s that the hard problems, like aligning incentives, measuring value, and preserving trust between physicians and those who pay them, follow you no matter which system you choose.

Check for yourself

Scroll to Top